|
| |
The Bottleneck Subjects
Shaun Kerry, M.D.
Diplomate, American Board
of Psychiatry and Neurology
Have you ever wondered
why lawyers, doctors, plumbers,
electricians, and air-conditioning specialists charge so much money for
their services?
|
 |
 |
|
One reason is that these subjects are excluded
from high school and college curricula. Classes
directly pertaining to the above mentioned trades are simply absent from
our schools.
In order for someone to enter one of these 'bottleneck' fields, they
must receive specialized training at an entirely separate
institution. This places a huge economic burden on both the
students who want to enter these fields, and the public who need these
services. The bottleneck acts to restrain free trade, and drives
up the cost. Students should have the freedom to choose their own
curriculum, and this doesn't only apply to existing academic subjects
and classes. Just like the student who is interested in math and
can learn math in the classroom, the student who wants to become an
electrician should be able to learn about this trade through the public
school system.
The bottleneck subjects would attract a great deal
of interest from students.
The major problem is that they are difficult to teach, but there is a
solution. We could record televised (via satellite) presentations
pertaining to the aforementioned trades, and show these programs using
large screen projection monitors. This would provide stimulating,
entertaining sessions for the students, while requiring very little
preparation on the part of the teachers. Additionally, teachers
could learn from the programs alongside their students. In an age
of 'McDonaldization' and efficiency, it seems utterly inefficient to
prepare the same educational presentation a thousand times, when it
could be done only once and digitally recorded. The curriculum
could alternate between videos and discussion groups. The class
could vote on which videos would be shown, and decide what portion of
class time would be designated for discussion. |
|
 |
 |
We need to bridge the gap between the classroom and the outside world.
Remember, real learning can take place outside of school just as
effectively as it can in school. It is also important to give
students credit for past or present outside work experience. The
classroom day could be shortened for students who have jobs that are
instructive.
We must endorse the notion
|
| that every person has value, no matter what
his walk of life. Our academic system discriminates against
students who have an aptitude for trades. Students who might be
interested in becoming plumbers or electricians are often discouraged by
counselors who would prefer them to enter more academic fields.
But remember, schools should be adapting to the needs of the students,
rather than the reverse. If a child wants to pursue a trade, he
should be encouraged to do so, rather than coerced into changing his
mind.
We often hear teachers complaining that they can't control their
students. The solution to this problem is to stop
trying to control them. Education should be an invitation, not an
issue of force. The school should make every attempt to come to terms
with each student. If this is not possible, then it is better to
allow the student to find his own solution, outside the classroom if
necessary. Using coercive force is damaging to both students and
teachers.
If these programs are developed in the United States, they can be
used in other countries
at little or no cost. Inefficiency in education is a worldwide
concern. With relevant, effective educational programs, less
developed countries would prosper. A major defect of the
accreditation process in these areas - medicine, law, etc - is that it
is based on written tests. There are many competent, bright, and
creative people who are not skillful test takers. For example,
someone may be a very capable and responsible tile layer, but not be
able to pass the written exam to get his contractors license.
Someone else may be a poor tile layer, but a good test taker. And
guess which one gets their license, hires people to do the work for
them, and pockets most of the money? Our society must understand
that test taking skills do not equal competence. An alternative
method of measuring competency would be oral exams and/or on-the-job
evaluations.
PRINTABLE PAGE
|
BACK
| TOP | NEXT
|
PRINTABLE SITE
|
|
|